home / subscribe / donate / tower / books / archives / search / links / feedback / events

 

What You're Missing in our subscriber-only CounterPunch newsletter
EX-STATE DEPT.SECURITY OFFICER SPELLS OUT 9/11 COVER-UP

Official Describes "Hands Off" CIA/FBI Response to Al Qaeda 1994 Assassination Plan for Clinton in Manila, Says It Points to Pakistan's ISI Involvement in 9/11 Attack, Passed Over by 9/11 Commission Vijay Prashad reports on Neoliberalism-as-Theft, defied by India's Left in fierce strikes Paul Craig Roberts Dissects US Jobs Decline and NYT's PollyAnna Reporting Gabriel Kolko on How Crazed America Will Destroy NATO Smearing Hugo Chavez as Anti-Semite
CounterPunch Online is read by millions of viewers each month! But remember, we are funded solely by the subscribers to the print edition of CounterPunch. Please support this website by buying a subscription to our newsletter, which contains fresh material you won't find anywhere else, or by making a donation for the online edition. Remember contributions are tax-deductible.
Click here to make a donation. If you find our site useful please: Subscribe Now!

Get CounterPunch By Email for Only $35 a Year

Today's Stories

February 28, 2006

Sharon Smith
Racism Thrives

February 27, 2006

Buncombe / Cockburn
And Now Come the Death Squads

Paul Craig Roberts
Twilight of the Hegemony

Ingmar Lee
Bush Mired in India's Nuclear Fallout: the Smiling Buddha Blast

Ron Jacobs
Death Squads, Shrine Bombs, Civil War: Iraq Going According to the Plan?

Dave Lindorff
Bush's Bunker Days

Pat Wolff
Sleeper Cells in South Dakota? The State of Mandatory Motherhood

Lila Rajiva
Double Standards on Foreign Owners: Amdocs vs. DP World

Website of the Day
Get Ya Hustle On!

 

February 25 / 26, 2006

Alexander Cockburn
Quail in War and Peace

Lila Rajiva
Chertoff Strikes Again

Lee Sustar
Target: Iran

Jennifer Van Bergen / Madis Senner
The Case of Dr. Rafil Dhafir

Justin E.H. Smith
David Horowitz's Odd Gripe

Paul Craig Roberts
Bush Hides Behind Supply-Side Economics to Reward His Cronies

Jason Leopold
Cheney Exposed?: New Emails in Plame Case Point to Veep's Role

Gilad Atzmon
In Support of My Mayor

Zahid Shariff
What's Going On in Pakistan?

Fred Gardner
Investigating Dr. Denney

Dick J. Reavis
What the UAE / Seaports Deal Teaches Us

David Stocker
Snow Job: the Privatization of US Ports

John Bomar
Losing on Every Front

Mike Marqusee
The Marchers Were Right

Pratyush Chandra
Bush's Passage to India

Ben Tripp
Rewriting History

Dr. Susan Block
Life, Death and Cartoons

Poets' Basement
Landau, Guthrie, LaMorticella, Engel and Mazza

Website of the Weekend
Toward Freedom

 

February 24, 2006

Alan Maass
War Crimes and Hunting Misdemeanors

William S. Lind
The Coming Fall of Pakistan

Dave Lindorff
Useless Democrats: a Whig's Worth of Difference?

Pierre Tristam
Iraq's Cambodian Jungle

Meg Bannerji
Bush's Port Deal: Who's the Dummy?

Robert Jensen
The Failures of Our First Amendment Successes

Mark Engler
How Costly is Too Costly?: Finding the Budgetary Tipping Point for Iraq

Jennifer Loewenstein
Watching the Dissolution of Palestine

Website of the Day
Katrina and the Failure of Black Leadership

 

February 23, 2006

Chet Richards
Rumsfeld's New Model Military: Creating Stability or Insurgency?

Jonathan Feldman
Dubaigate Deconstructed

Joshua Frank
The Democrats' Pull Out Method: Another Election Year Stunt?

Ron Jacobs
Volunteers of America: the Politics of the Weather Underground

Amira Hass
Separate and Unequal: Forbidden to Go Home Together

Samah Sabawi
Hamas and the Missing Video: Editorial Delusions at the Globe and Mail

Norman Solomon
The Unreal Death of Journalism

Christopher Reed
Japan's Neo-Militarists

Website of the Day
Is the Pentagon Making an Anthrax Bomb in Utah?

 

February 22, 2006

Robert Pollin
Reaganomics Revisited: Beyond the Glow of Nostalgia

Phil Doe
How to Pay for War and Cut Taxes for the Rich: Sell Off the Public Lands

Pirouz Azadi
Looking Middle Eastern? You are a Prime Suspect

Saul Landau
Memo to the Dems: Doesn Anyone Give a Damn?

Brian McKinlay
Howard's End?: Trouble Down Under

Sam Smith
Real Holocaust Denial

Niranjan Ramakrishnan
Could You Please Pass the Port?

Diane Farsetta
The Pentagon's Media Contracts: the Wages of Spin

Website of the Day
Port of No Return: Bin Laden, the Taliban and the UAE

 

February 21, 2006

Paul Craig Roberts
Would Someone Please Interfere in Our Elections?

Franklin Spinney
Arab Democracy American-Style: Or How to Lose a 4th Generation War

Dave Lindorff
Chasing Cheney in the Ambulance

Alevtina Rea
Ethics, Morals and Empire

Bruce K. Gagnon
The Dems' Latest Stall Strategy: "Strategic Redeployment"

Dave Zirin
Whiteblindness: the Winter Olympics, Bryant Gumbel and Racism at ESPN

Bill Quigley
Six Months After Katrina: Who Was Left Behind Then? Who is Being Left Behind Now?

Website of the Day
Soldiers and Students

 

February 20, 2006

Jennifer Van Bergen
The Perversions of the Bush Administration: Sexual Humiliation and Mother Murder in the War on Terror

Rachard Itani
The Bigoted Wombat: John Howard Does Abu Ghraib

Gideon Levy
A Chilling Heartlessness

Joshua Frank
Cindy Sheehan's Message to the Democrats

Newton Garver
The Challenges and Opportunities Confronting Evo Morales

Pratyush Chandra
What the US Ambassador Taught Nepalis

Seth Sandronsky
Bubblicious: the US Real Estate Market

Cockburn / St. Clair
The FBI and the Myth of Fingerprints

Website of the Day
Chickenhawks Hall of Shame

 

February 18 / 19, 2006

Werther
A Half-Dozen Questions About 9/11 They Don't Want You to Ask

Uzma Aslam Khan
Live from Lahore: Watching with Glee

Joe DeRaymond
A Case of Injustice in Pennsylvania: the Prosecution of Dennis Counterman

Edward F. Mooney
Is Liberalism a Failing Religion? The Case of the Danish Cartoons

Paul Craig Roberts
From Conservatives to Brownshirts

Elaine Cassel
The Sentencing of Zacarias Moussaoui: an Issue of Competency

P. Sainath
Soaring Suicides in Vidharbha

Thomas P. Healy
An Interview with Ann Wright

Brian Concannon, Jr.
Haiti's Elections: Right Result; Wrong Procedure

Fred Gardner
Health Savings Accounts: a Boon for the Bosses

Rep. Cynthia McKinney
Katrina's New Underclass

Brian Tokar
WTO vs. Europe: Less (and More) Than It Seems

Chan Chee Khoon
Privatizing the World Bank?

Andrew Freedman
Chicago's Panopticon

St. Clair / Walker
Playlists: What We're Listening to This Week

Poets' Basement
Hassen, Anderson, Engel and Guthrie

Website of the Weekend
Depictionary

 

February 17, 2006

Floyd Rudmin
Secret War Plans and the Malady of American Militarism

Gervasio Rodríguez
FBI Home Invasions in Puerto Rico

Gary Leupp
The Mad is No Longer Out of the Question: Stopping the War on Iran Before It Starts

Ramzy Baroud
Weathering the Globalization Storm

Amira Hass
Apartheid Gates: IDF Establishes "Israeli Only" Crossings

Matthew Koehler
Forest Abuse on the Kootenai: an Intervention in Montana

Niranjan Ramakrishnan
Deadeye Dick: Who Dares Call Him Chickenhawk Now?

Debbie Nathan
ABC's Primetime "Teen Sex Slaves" Scam

Website of the Day
Black Mesa Defense

 

Febrauary 16, 2006

Lila Rajiva
Torture Pictures That Didn't Make the Exhibition

Norman Solomon
Dick Cheney's Fox Trot

Ron Jacobs
An Interview with Antiwar Faster Mike Ferner

Paul Craig Roberts
Their Own Economic Reality

Website of the Day
This Ain't No Video Game


February 15, 2006

Brian Conacnnon, Jr.
Haiti's Elections: Chaos, Supression and Fraud

Dave Lindorff
Democrats Shoot Their Own, Too

Saree Makdisi
Israeli Ultimatums

Joshua Frank
The Rhetorical Gore

Amira Hass
Down the Expulsion Highway

CounterPunch Wire
Winter of Discontent: a 34-Day Fast Against the War

Robert Bryce
The United States of Enron

Website of the Day
Osama's Game: an Interview with Michael Scheuer

February 14, 2006

John Sugg
Those Cartoons and the Neo Con: Daniel Pipes and the Danish Editor

Don Santina
DiFi and the Royal Democrats: the Curious Withdrawal of Cindy Sheehan

William A. Cook
Shaming Sharon

Ray McGovern
Who Will Blow the Whistle About Iran?

John Ross
Bush's Mexican Poodle

Website of the Day
Willie Nelson Records CPer Ned Sublette's "Cowboys Are Frequently Secretly"


February 13, 2006

Lila Rajiva
Axis of Child Abusers: UK Troops Beat Up Barefoot Iraqi Teens

Christopher Brauchli
Whistleblowers and Witch Hunters: the Bush Inquisition

Dave Lindorff
Deadeye Dick: If Stupidity Were Impeachable, Cheney Would Be History

Ron Jacobs
Black Liberation

Mike Whitney
Riding High with Hugo Chavez

Michael Neumann
Respectful Cultures and Disrespectful Cartoons

Website of the Day
Virtual Resistance

 

February 11 / 12, 2006

Alexander Cockburn
How Not to Spot a Terrorist

Ralph Nader
Bringing Democracy to the Federal Reserve

Paul Craig Roberts
Nuking the Economy

Pat Williams
John Boehner's Dirty Little Secret: Flying Lobbyist Air at $4,000 a Junket

Fred Gardner
Dr. Mikuriya's Appeal: a Last Minute Twist

Saul Landau
From Munich to Hamas

John Chuckman
Cartoons and Bombs: Was Rice Right for Once?

Roger Burbach
Evo Morales: the Early Days

Seth Sandronsky
Economy on Ice

Website of the Weekend
Just Say Know

 

February 10, 2006

Carl G. Estabrook
A US War Plan for Khuzestan?

Sen. Russell Feingold
A Raw Deal on the Patriot Act

Roxanne Dunbar----Ortiz
How Did Evo Morales Come to Power?

Saree Makdisi
The Tempest Over the Hamas Charter

Website of the Day
The New York Art Scene: 1974----1984

 

 

February 9, 2006

Dave Lindorff
Bush and Yamashita: War Crimes and Commanders-in-Chief

Mike Marqusee
The Human Majority was Right About Iraq

Paul Craig Roberts
How Conservatives Went Crazy: the Rightwing Press

Peter Phillips
Inside the Global Dominance Group: 200 Insiders Against the World

William S. Lind
Rumsfeld the Maximalist: the Long War

Christine Tomlinson Innocent Targets in the "Long War": False Positives and Bush's Eavesdropping Program

Will Youmans
Church of England Votes to Divest from Israel

Robert Robideau
An American Indian's View of the Cartoons

Richard Neville
The Cartoons That Shook the World: All This from the Danes, the Least Funny People on Earth

Peter Rost
The New Robber Barons

Website of the Day
Eyes Wide Open

 

February 8, 2006

Ron Jacobs
The Once and Future Sly Stone: Soundtrack to a Riot

Stan Cox
Making and Unmaking History with General Myers

Sen. Russ Feingold
Why Bush's Wiretapping Program is Illegal and Unconstitutional

Robert Jensen
Horowitz's Academic Hit List: Take a Class from One of the CounterPunch 16

Rep. Cynthia McKinney
Bush Should Have Wiretapped FEMA and Chertoff

Niranjan Ramakrishnan
Alberto Gonzales Channels Mark Twain

Don Monkerud
Covenant Marriage on the Rocks

David Swanson
Inequality and War

C.L. Cook
Nuking Ontario

Christopher Fons
Chill Out Jihadis: They're Just Cartoons!

Jeffrey Ballinger
The Other Side of Nike and Social Responsibility

Website of the Day
Encyclopedia of Terrorism in the Americas

 

February 7, 2006

Edward Lucie-Smith
An Urgent Plea to Save a Small Estonian Museum from Neo-Nazis

Robert Fisk
The Fury: Now Lebanon is Burning

Paul Craig Roberts
Colin Powell's Career as a "Yes Man"

Neve Gordon
Why Hamas Won

Joshua Frank
The Hillary and George Show: Partners in War

Peter Montague
The Problem with Mercury: a History of Regulatory Capitulation

Jackie Corr
The Last Best Choice: Public Power and Montana

Jeffrey St. Clair
Rumsfeld's Enforcer: the Secret World of Stephen Cambone

Website of the Day
Negroes with Guns

 

February 6, 2006

Christopher Brauchli
Spilling Blood: Two Sentences

Robert Fisk
Don't Be Fooled: This Isn't About Islam vs. Secularism

John Chuckman
What Did Stephen Harper Actually Win?

Jenna Orkin
Judge Slams EPA for Lying About 9/11's Toxic Air

Paul Craig Roberts
Who Will Save America: My Epiphany

 

February 4 / 5, 2006

Alexander Cockburn
"Lights Out in Tehran": McCain Starts Bombing Run

Mike Ferner
Pentagon Database Leaves No Kid Alone

James Petras
Evo Morales's Cabinet: a Bizarre Beginning in Bolivia

Alan Maass
Scare of the Union: Dems Collaborate with Bush on Surveillance

Fred Gardner
Annals of Law Enforcement: a Look Inside the San Francisco DA's Office

Ralph Nader
Bush's Energy Escapades

Bill Glahn
RIAA Watch: Speaking in Tongues

Saul Landau
Freedom 2006: Buying Sex on the Net or Those Older Freedoms?

Laura Carlsen
Bad Blood on the Border: Killing Guillermo Martinez

James Brooks
Our Little Shop of Diplomatic Horrors

Mike Roselle
Hippies and Revolutionaries in Carcacas

John Holt
Black Gold, Black Death: Canada's Oil Sands Frenzy

Sarah Ferguson
Cops Suing Cops ... for Spying on Cops

William S. Lind
Beware the Ides of March

Niranjan Ramakrishnan
The Price of Globalization: Free Trade or Free Speech?

Seth Sandronsky
The Color of Job Cuts in the Auto Industry

Derrick O'Keefe
Rumsfeld's Hitler Analogy

Michael Donnelly
Hop on the Bus

Ron Jacobs
Religion and Political Power

Elisa Salasin
RSVP to Bush

St. Clair / Vest
Playlists: What We're Listening to This Week

Stew Albert
God's Curse: Selected Poems

Poets' Basement
Guthrie, LaMorticella and Engel

Website of the Weekend
Killer Tells All!

 

February 3, 2006

Toufic Haddad
A Parliament of Prisoners

Heather Gray
Working with Coretta Scott King

Tim Wise
Racism, Neo-Confederacy and the Raising of Historical Illiterates

Conn Hallinan
Nuclear Proliferation: the Gathering Storm

Eva Golinger
Rumsfeld and Negroponte Amp Up Hositility Toward Venezuela

Daniel Ellsberg
The World Can't Wait: Invitation to a Demonstration

Dave Zirin
Detroit: Super Bowl City on the Brink

Robert Bryce
The Problem with Cutting US Oil Imports from the Middle East

Website of the Day
The Chavez Code

 

February 2, 2006

Winslow T. Wheeler
Pentagon Pork: How to Eliminate It

Stan Cox
Outsourcing the Golden Years

Rachard Itani
Danes (Finally) Apologize to Muslims (For the Wrong Reasons)

Mike Whitney
Afghanistan Five Years Later: Buildings Down, Heroin Up

Amira Hass
In the Footsteps of Arafat: an Interview with Hamas' Ismail Haniya

Norman Solomon
When Praise is Desecration: Smothering King's Legacy with Kind Words

Michael Simmons
Stew Lives!

Christopher Reed
Japan's Dirty Secret: One Million Korean Slaves

Website of the Day
State of Nature

 

February 1, 2006

Sharon Smith
The Bluff and Bluster Dems: Alito and the Faux Filibuster

Jason Leopold
Enron and the Bush Administration

Cindy Sheehan
Getting Busted at the State of the Union: What Really Happened

Joseph Grosso
Oprah and Elie Wiesel: a Match Made in "Neutrality"

Earl Ofari Hutchinson
Coretta Scott King was More Than Just Dr. King's Wife

Steven Higgs
Life After Roe. v. Wade

Robert Robideau
"God Given Rights": Palestine and Native America

R. Siddharth
Tales of Power: When Gandhi Rejected a Faustian Bargain with Henry Ford

Jim Retherford
Remembering Stew Albert: the Quiet Genius

Rep. Cynthia McKinney
The Legacy of Coretta Scott King

Paul Craig Roberts
The True State of the Union

Website of the Day
Candide's Notebooks

 

January 31, 2006

Jeffrey St. Clair
Revolutionary for the Hell of It: the Good Life of Stew Albert

Clancy Chassay
US Prods Lebanon Towards Civil War

Dave Lindorff
The Democrats' Alito Debacle

Niranjan Ramakrishnan
Alito: Harry-Kerry in the Senate

Oren Ben-Dor
Hamas' Victory: a New Hope?

Winslow Wheeler
Pentagon Pork: What is It? Who Cooks It Up?

John Ryan
Canada: a Chilling Echo of Bush's Republicans

Mike Marqusee
Privatizing Health Care: the Poor Pay the Price

Ron Jacobs
For Stew

Andrew Cockburn
Why Bush Probably Won't Attack Iran

Website of the Day
Celebrating Stew Albert

 

January 30, 2006

Paul Craig Roberts
Bush, Fox News and the Coming War on Iran

Winslow Wheeler
Inside the Pork Shop: the Defense Budget and Congressional Earmarks

Niranjan Ramakrishnan
Development Interrupted

Marcus Dam
"The Real Threat is from Imperial Fundamentalism": an Interview with Tariq Ali

John Bomar
Message to Democrats: the Case Against Pre-War Lying is a Slam Dunk, Stupid

Ben Beachy
Swindling the Sick: the IMF Debt Relief Sham

Gideon Levy
The Good News About Hamas' Victory

Michael Carmichael
Alito and Opus Dei

Missy Comley Beattie
Of Losses and Lies

Norman Solomon
The Question Journalists Refuse to Ask Bush

Brian Concannon, Jr.
Finally Some Good News From Haiti

Michael Ratner
Tomorrow is Today; the Time for Resistance is Now

Website of the Day
"I'm So Bored with Capitol Hill"

 

January 28 / 29, 2006

Alexander Cockburn
Nicholas Kristof's Brothel Problem

Ralph Nader
The Impeachable Mr. Bush

Col. Dan Smith
Spying and Lying by the Pentagon

Paul Craig Roberts
Blind Ignorance: Polls Show Many Americans Simply Dumber Than Bush

Tammara Rosenleaf
Homefront War Diary: On Monday, My Husband Didn't Call

Ron Jacobs
Google This!

Harry Browne
Irish "Peace" Process at Recriminations Stage

Fred Gardner
Grover Norquist, Drug Policy Reformer?

Christopher Reed
North Korean Forgeries

Bernard Chazelle
France's Colonial Blowback

Daniel Wolff
Radioactive Money, 2005: How Entergy Gets Its Way at Indian Point

Tom Kerr
Small Fry: If You're Not in Power, You'd Better Not Lie

Asad Abu Khalil
The Demise of Fatah

Chris Murphy
The Medicare Disaster

Dr. Susan Block
America Wants a Divorce

Kathy Deacon
Hippocratic Oaf

St. Clair / Walker / Palmer / Shields
Playlists: What We're Listening to This Week

Poets' Basement
Laymon, Engel, Holt, Davies and Buknatski

Website of the Weekend
Your Child Can Be a NSA Spook!


January 27, 2006

Suren Pillay
Making the World Safe for Nuclear Violence, Again

Lawrence R. Velvel
The NYT and Alito: Journalistic Schizophrenia

J.L. Chestnut, Jr
The Cold Hard Truth: Marching Backwards on Civil Rights

Uri Avnery
To Talk with Hamas

Gary Leupp
Hamas's Victory: "the Power of Democracy"

Samar Assad
A New Political Landscape in Palestine

Jeffrey St. Clair
King of the Hill: Sen. Ted Steven's Empire of Corruption

Website of the Day
Bush Jobs Program: You Too Can Be an FBI Snitch

 

January 26, 2006

Robert Robideau
An AIM Activist's View of Jack Abramoff: Another Racist Out to Defraud Native Tribes

Paul Craig Roberts
Bolton Orders Syria to Do the Impossible

Gilad Atzmon
Hamas' Victory

Jason Leopold
A Vaster Conspiracy?: Fitzgerald Probes Niger Forgeries

Joshua Frank
Iran, Nukes and Oil

Dave Lindorff
Bush Calls Hamas Kettle Black

Susan Lee
An Open Letter to the State Dept. on the Cuban Five

Missy Comley Beattie
A Plea to the Marines: Stop Sending Recruiting Letters to Our House!

Michael Carmichael
Extraordinary Alito

Michael Neumann
The Core of Zionism

Website of the Day
Who Will Stop the Slaughter of Yellowstone's Bison?

 

January 25, 2006

Saul Landau
Domestic Spying, Now and Then: When Hoover Bugged Phone Calls with My Father

James Petras
Is Chile's Bachelet Washington's Best New Ally?

Lawrence R. Velvel
Alito and Roberts' Self-Gag Rule is a Phony

Vijay Prashad
From Chennai with Love

Kevin Zeese
Gen. William Odom Supports the Empire, But Opposes the War

Alison Weir
When a Mother Gets Killed Does She Make a Sound? Anatomy of a Cover-Up

Bruce K. Gagnon
Bush War Economy: Exporting Jobs and Security

Joan Roelofs
Military Contractor Philanthropy

Website of the Day
Bob Marley Does Dylan

 

January 24, 2006

Paul Craig Roberts
The Patriot Police: the Unfathomed Dangers of Patriot Act Reauthorization

Kathy Kelly
Liberation and Deliverance

Jorge Mariscal
Bush's War Viewed from the South

Winslow T. Wheeler
Smoke and Mirrors in the Defense Budget

John Walsh
Why We Picket John Kerry: Join Us Friday in Boston

Youmans / Muaddi
The Growing Israel Divestment Movement

Roger Burbach
Bolivia's Evo Morales: Original Mandate for Social Revolution

Fr. Gerard Jean-Juste
Letter from a Haitian Prison

Noam Chomsky
The Terrorist in the Mirror

Website of the Day
Big Brother Watch


January 23, 2006

Uri Avnery
Pity the Orphan: Israel, Hamas and the Palestinian Elections

Susan Pynchon
Diebold in Florida: "I Saw It Hacked"

William Loren Katz
Harry Belafonte Reaffirms a Proud Tradition

Christopher Brauchli
Bush's IRS: Squeezing the Poor

Chris Floyd
The Goon Show

Joshua Frank
Tre Arrow and ELF: Environmentalism on Death Row

Norman Solomon
The Other Shoe Drops: Classified Leaks and Journalists

Jackie Corr
Working for the Railroad: Racicot and the Burlington Northern

Paul Craig Roberts
Inside Cheney's War Workshop

Website of the Day
Arms Against War

 

January 21/22, 2006

Tim Shorrock
Why the Buses Didn't Come: Bush-Linked Florida Company and the Katrina Evacuation Fiasco

Ralph Nader
Congressional Ethics After Abramoff

Peter Feng
Casualties of War: Neoliberalism, Katrina and the Asian Tsunami

Brian Cloughley
CIA Bombs Pakistan, Hits America

Michael Donnelly
Tapes and Snitches: Feds Hand Down Eco-Sabotage Indictments

Tom Kerr
Crackdown in San Quentin: Why are They Rounding Up Tookie Williams' Friends?

Tim Matson
Best Not Drive While Black on I-91 (But Walk Tall With the Bloody Chainsaw You Just Topped Your Neighbor With)

Dave Lindorff
Rumsfeld: Venezuela "Overspending" on Military

Daniel Wolff
Hour of Reckoning: the Gospel Roots of Wilson Pickett

Fred Gardner
"Metabolic Syndrome" is to "Clinical Depression" as Acomplia is Prozac

Jason Leopold
How Cheney Used the NSA to Spy on Americans Prior to 9/11

Matthew Koehler
Betting on Biscuit: Does Post-Fire Logging Make Ecological (or Economic) Sense?

John Bomar
The Emperor's Clothes: from Bonaparte to Bush

Ron Jacobs
When Miners March: Struggle and Lose, Struggle and Win!

Becky Akers
Debunking Democracy

Joanne Mariner
Security, Terrorism and Human Rights

St. Clair / Walker / Pollack
CounterPunch Playlists: What We're Listening to This Week

Poets' Basement
Albert, Holt, Engel and Davies

Website of the Day
Osama's Book Club: Featured Selection


January 20, 2006

Brian J. Foley
What Kind of War Doesn't Allow for a Truce?

Richard Gott
Revolution in the Andes

Joshua Frank
Israel and US Threats Against Iran

Pierre Tristam
Imperial Mongers: From Gladstone to "King George"

Bernstein / Allegretto
Hourly Wages Have Fallen in 18 of the Last 20 Months

Elizabeth Schulte
Abortion Before Roe

Website of the Day
This Dog Bites

 

January 19, 2006

Paul Craig Roberts
Political Machines: Was the 2004 Election Stolen?

Bill Simpich
Those Damn Democrats: To End War, Don't Ask for What You Don't Want

Kevin Alexander Gray
Reclaiming King Day (From the NAACP)

Sam Husseini
Rot at the Top: If the Democrats Really Want to Stop Bush, They Need New Leadership

Sam Smith
The Real Chocolate City

Monica Benderman
Dare to Make a Stand

Winslow T. Wheeler
Just How Big is the Defense Budget?

Website of the Day
Leave My Child Alone

 

January 18, 2006

Paul Craig Roberts
Gore's Speech: a Challenge That Cannot be Ignored

Norman Solomon
The Crime of Giving the Orders: Executing Clarence Ray Allen

Jonathan M. Feldman
The System Doesn't Work Anymore

Michael Carmichael
"Extraordinary Circumstances": the Case Against Alito

Paul D'Amato
The Crimes of Jimmy Carter

Cynthia McKinney
King's Mission Endures

Norman Finkelstein
Why an Economic Boycott of Israel is Justified

Website of the Day
The Planetary Movement

 

January 17, 2006

M. Shahid Alam
"Real Men Go to Tehran": Has al-Qaeda's Gambit Paid Off?

John Ross
Latin America's Indians on the Move--in Different Directions

Tariq Ali
God, Blood, Oil and Iraq

Michael Donnelly
Killing Anna Mae Aquash, Smearing John Trudell

Amira Hass
No Child Left Unharassed: the Obstacle Course to School in Palestine

Doug Giebel
Alito's CAP: Either He Lied on His Resumé or There's a Cover-Up

Bill Quigley
MLK Day in a Haitian Prison

Ron Jacobs
Meet the Son of Jim Crow: MLK Day Below the Mason/Dixon Line

Mike Stark
Governor on a Killling Spree

Werther
The Liberties of the Subject


January 16, 2006

John Walsh
Tears of a Neocon: The Good News from Daniel Pipes

Earl Ofari Hutchinson
Black Students Under Fire: Racial Profiling in Public Schools

Roger Burbach
Bachelet's Victory: Leftward Drift in Chile?

Norman Solomon
Ted Koppel, NPR and Henry Kissinger: a Natural Fit?

Robert Jensen
Dreams and Nightmares: How Would King Judge America?

Sam Husseini
Martin Luther King and the Deeper Malady

Paul Craig Roberts
Bush Crosses the Rubicon

Website of the Day
MLK: Beyond Vietnam

 

January 14 / 15, 2006

Alexander Cockburn
What the FBI Repairman Wore When He Tried to Bug Edward Said

JoAnn Wypijewski
What is an Antiwar Movement?

James Petras
The State of the Empire, 2006

Ron Jacobs
Fifteen Years of War: Who's Better Off?

Brian Cloughley
Fly Boys and Lie Boys: Smart-Bombing Iraqi Families While They Sleep

Marianne McDonald
The Madness of Ajax: a Play for Our Time

Bruce Tyler Wick
Bush on Torture Echoes Charles I on Arbitrary Imprisonment

Fred Gardner
A Last, Desperate Plea to Stay in Canada

Flavia Alaya
Victory at Passaic County Jail

Gary Leupp
A Neocon Plan to Plant WMDs?

Dr. Susan Block
Peeping Tom in the Bush: Nonconsenual Voyeurism and the NSA

Nicole Colson
The House Jack Built: The Abramoff Giude to Buying Friends and Influencing Politics

Jeffrey Kolakowski
Senator as Illusionist: the Hypocrisies of John McCain

Missy Comley Beattie
The Stepford Hearings of Samuel Alito: The Senator, the Weepy Wife and a Secret Annoiting

Charles Thomson
Is Serota Dead in the Water?: the Ofili Scandal at the Tate

St. Clair / Walker / Vest
Playlsts: What We're Listening to This Week

Poets' Basement
Albert, Engel, Ford and Davies

Website of the Weekend
Historians Against the War

 

January 13, 2006

Ralph Nader
The Two Questions the Senate Should Have Asked Alito

Leonard Weinglass
The Singular Story of the Cuban Five

Amira Hass
Prisoners in Their Own Land: 800,000 Palestinians Sealed Off by IDF in West Bank

Chris Kutalik / Jennifer Biddle
Airline Workers Fight Back

Lawrence R. Velvel
Alito and the Democrats

Dave Lindorff
Eight Who Dared: a (Short) Congressional Honor Roll

Mike Whitney
Countdown to War with Iran?

David Price
How the FBI Spied on Edward Said

 

January 12, 2006

Jennifer Van Bergen
The Unitary Executive: Why the Bush Doctrine Violates the Constitution

Jeremy Brecher / Brendan Smith
Command Responsibility: Torture and Legal Accountability

Lawrence R. Velvel
Alito Refuses to Answer Fundamental Questions

Ralph Nader / Robert Weissman
Corporations, Originalism and the Bill of Rights: an Open Letter to Justice Scalia

Jackie Corr
Killing the Big Sky's Golden Goose: Marc Racicot and the Deregulation of Montana Power

Jared Bernstein
The Wage Doldrums

Russell D. Hoffman
New Horizons in Space, New Lows in Government

Aubrey Streit
I Was Born in a Small Town: the Fate of Rural America

Clancy Sigal
Hugh Thompson and My Lai: He Broke Ranks; He Did the Right Thing

Website of the Day
Nukes in Space

 

January 11, 2006

Kevin Zeese
NSA Spied on Baltimore Peace Group (And They've Got the Documents That Prove It)

Ray McGovern
The Big Wiretap

Allan Maass / Joe Allen
Schwarzenegger's Hit List: Smearing Mandela, Killing Tookie

Earl Ofari Hutchinson
Snatching at King's Legacy: Mythmaking, Profiteering & Outright Distortions

Annie Murphy
Evo Morales' Sweater

Allan Lichtman
Abramoff's Kind of Big Government

Ramzy Baroud
Politics of Chaos: Gaza's Turmoil in Context

Joshua Frank
MoveOn Surrenders to Hillary

Kathleen and Bill Christison
"Eating Palestine for Breakfast": the Real Sharon

Website of the Day
Memoirs of Rummy's Geisha

 

January 10, 2006

Uri Avnery
The Post-Sharon Landscape: Three Fingers, No Fist

Saul Landau
Different Americas

Noam Chomsky
Beyond the Ballot: Iraq, Iran and China

Brian J. Foley
Playing with Fire: Congress and Executive Power

Lenni Brenner
The War Within the Antiwar Movement

Ronan Sheehan
Sheehan to Sheehan: Cindy Sheehan's Irish Interview

Paul Craig Roberts
Bush's Con Jobs

 

January 9, 2006

Behzad Yaghmaian
Who is to Blame for the Deaths of the Sudanese Refugees?

George Bisharat
US Aid to Israel is Out of Hand

Dave Lindorff
How the US Press Squelches Bush Impeachment Drive

Norman Solomon
Smoke a Marlboro, Then an Iraqi: How Media War Images Distort Not Inform

Christopher Brauchli
The Generosity of Credit Card Companies

Aharon Shabtai
A Poet's Letter on the Occupation

Andrew Cockburn
How Many Iraqis Have Died Since the US Invasion in 2003?

 

January 7 / 8, 2006

Lawrence Velvel
The NYT's Unconscionable Decision to Sit on the NSA Story for a Year

James Petras
AIPAC on Trial: Them or US

J.L. Chestnut
Racism and Injustice in Alabama's Courts

Mike Ely
The Dead Miners in Sago

Andrew Wilson
The Dying of Ariel Sharon

Lila Rajiva
Two Moms Go to Capitol Hill

William Cook
The Rape of Palestine

Ramor Ryan
The Sub Motorcycle Diaries: On the Road with the Zapatistas

Thomas Kleine-Brockhoff
An Interview with Michael Scheuer on the CIA's Rendition Program

Peter Montague
Inherit the Wind: the Global Spread of GMO Crops

Ron Jacobs
Would Ethan Allen Pay to Protest?

Neve Gordon
Images of Real Eco-Terrorism in Twaneh

Fred Gardner
Business as Usual in San Diego

Josh Mahon
Idaho Timber Industry Leader Advocates Violence Against Green's Mom

Dr. Susan Block
Abramoff Family Values: the Lobbyist Who Screwed Us All

Jeffrey St. Clair
Playlist: What I'm Listening to This Week

Poets' Basement
Albert and Engel

Website of the Weekend
Bush Crimes Commission

 

January 6, 2006

José Pertierra
Posada Carriles May Soon Hit the Streets

Joe Allen
Gary Freeman's Struggle: a Black Radical from the 1960s Fights Extradition to the US

Winslow T. Wheeler
Huge Defense Budget, Lousy Equipment

John Bomar
A Former NSA Officer on Snoopgate: the Squawkers Should be Congratulated

Jason Leopold
Snoop and Shred

Norman Solomon
Axis of Fanatics: Netanyahu and Ahmadinejad

Robert Pollin
Remembering Harry Magdoff: the Man Who Explained the Empire

 

January 5, 2006

Scott Boehm
Big Profits, Buried Lives: Bulldozing the Dead in New Orleans

Zoltan Grossman
New Challenges for the Antiwar Movement

Heather Gray
Whistling Dixie Yet Again

Haninah Levine
Simple is Dangerous: the Pentagon's Plan for a Manhattan Project on IEDs

Pierre Tristam
The Sham of Homeland Security: a West Virginia Parable

Remi Kanazi
Stroke of Luck?: Political Hemorrhage in Israel

Gilad Atzmon
Sharon Meets His Maker

Kathleen and Bill Christison
What Hillary Clinton Doesn't Know About Palestine

 

January 4, 2006

Ron Jacobs
Pity the Miner: A-Diggin' My Bones

Lila Rajiva
Terror Hits Bangalore

Huibin Amee Chew
Why the War is Sexist

Pat Williams
How the West Turned: Biting the Hands That Steal

Linda Milazzo
The House That George and Jack Built: Ownership Society Meets the Entrepreneurial Style

Nick Dearden
The Fantasy of "Even-Handedness": Blair's Cynical Policy on Palestine

James Petras
Evo Morales: All Growl, No Claws?

Website of the Day
Rat Out a Lobbyist for Jesus

 

January 3, 2006

James Ridgeway
Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and 9/11: How Much Did the Bush Administration Know?

Laith al-Saud
Iraqi Intellectuals and the Occupation: an Interview with Dr. Saad Jawad

Dick J. Reavis
Border Walls: the View from Mexico

Joshua Frank
Hillary Clinton, AIPAC and Iran

Rochelle Gause
Inside Rafah: Collective Punishment as Normalcy

Missy Comley Beattie
How My Mother Went from a Republican to a Screaming Progressive

Paul de Rooij
A Glossary of Dispossession

 

January 2, 2006

Paul Craig Roberts
A Gestapo Administration

Clancy Sigal
A Trip to the Far Side of Madness

Cindy Sheehan
A Tour of Europe: Friends Don't Let Friends Commit War Crimes

Alexander Cockburn
A NYT Editorial Contemplates Iraq

 

 

 

 

Subscribe Online

February 28, 2006

A Sham Process and a Rotten Deal

Renewing the Patriot Act

By Sen. RUSSELL FEINGOLD

Later today we will have a cloture vote on S. 2271. We should not end debate on this bill, and we should not pass this bill. Doing so will only help implement the deeply flawed deal that was struck with the White House to reauthorize the Patriot Act without enacting the core civil liberties protections for which so many of us have fought. I urge my colleagues to vote No on cloture.

Everyone in this body wants to reauthorize the Patriot Act. Many of the expiring provisions are entirely non-controversial. But we also need to fix the provisions that went too far, that do not contain the checks and balances necessary to protect our rights and freedoms. This reauthorization process is our chance to get it right, and moving forward with this bill takes us one step closer to wasting that chance.

Back in December, 46 Senators voted against cloture on the Patriot Act conference report. I think it's clear by now that the deal makes only minor changes to that conference report, which remains as flawed today as it was two months ago. The Senator from Pennsylvania, Chairman of the Judiciary Committee and primary proponent of the conference report in this body, was quoted as saying that the changes that the White House agreed to were "cosmetic." And then he said, according to the AP, "But sometimes cosmetics will make a beauty out of a beast and provide enough cover for senators to change their vote."

Since this deal was announced, editorial pages of newspapers also have pointed out how minimal these changes are, and have urged Senators not to change their votes. Let me read a few examples.

The editorial board of the Roanoke Times in Virginia had this to say on February 11: "A compromise that is expected to clear the way for the law's reauthorization is a victory of fear over strength. The 'compromise' the White House and congressional leaders reached this week on reauthorization of the USA Patriot Act is a compromise of the basic freedoms that define this nation. The Bush administration has made a few minor concessions, enough to give the handful of defiant Senate Republicans and some of their Democratic allies cover to extend the broad anti-terrorism bill and claim they have done what they could to protect the civil liberties of innocent Americans. They have not."

That same day, from the New York Times, we heard this: "The Patriot Act has been one of the few issues on which Congress has shown backbone lately. Last year, it refused to renew expiring parts of the act until greater civil liberties protections were added. But key members of the Senate have now caved, agreeing to renew these provisions in exchange for only minimal improvements. At a time when the public is growing increasingly concerned about the lawlessness of the Bush administration's domestic spying, the Senate should insist that any reauthorization agreement do more to protect Americans against improper secret searches."

And from my own home state, this is from the Wisconsin State Journal on February 18: "In recent weeks senators have worked with the White House to produce a compromise. However, the compromise remains far short of what is required to protect Americans' civil liberties. Regrettably, the Senate has backed down from its earlier stand and is poised to pass the inadequate bill."

These editorial boards and millions of Americans across the country recognize what everyone in this body already knows: that this deal makes only minor, yes cosmetic, changes to the conference report that was blocked in December. The deal is woefully inadequate. Let me explain why.

I want to start by reminding my colleagues of the context for this deal. Back in November and December when so many of us were fighting for improvements to the conference report, we made very clear what we were asking for. We laid out five issues that needed to be addressed to get our support. I'm going to read excerpts from a letter that we sent explaining our concerns, because I think it will help demonstrate why this deal is so bad. Here are the problems we identified and the changes we asked for several months ago.

On Section 215 we said:

The draft conference report would allow the government to obtain sensitive personal information on a mere showing of relevance. This would allow government fishing expeditions. As business groups like the U.S. Chamber of Commerce have argued, the government should be required to convince a judge that the records they are seeking have some connection to a suspected terrorist or spy.

Next we discussed gag orders, both for Section 215 orders and National Security Letters:

The draft conference report does not permit the recipient of a Section 215 order to challenge its automatic, permanent gag order. Courts have held that similar restrictions violate the First Amendment. The recipient of a Section 215 order is entitled to meaningful judicial review of the gag order.

The draft conference report does not provide meaningful judicial review of an NSL's gag order. It requires the court to accept as conclusive the government's assertion that a gag order should not be lifted, unless the court determines the government is acting in bad faith. The recipients of NSLs are entitled to meaningful judicial review of a gag order.

We then moved on to National Security Letters more generally:

The draft conference report does not sunset the NSL authority. In light of recent revelations about possible abuses of NSLs, the NSL provision should sunset in no more than four years so that Congress will have an opportunity to review the use of this power.

And finally we addressed sneak and peek search warrants:

The draft conference report requires the government to notify the target of a "sneak and peek" search no earlier than 30 days after the search, rather than within seven days, as the Senate bill provides and as pre-Patriot Act judicial decisions required. The conference report should include a presumption that notice will be provided within a significantly shorter period in order to better protect Fourth Amendment rights. The availability of additional 90-day extensions means that a shorter initial time frame should not be a hardship on the government.

Again, those quotes are from a letter that we sent late last year. Now, you might ask, in this newly announced deal on the Patriot Act, have any of these five problems been solved?

The answer is "No." Not a single one. Only one of these issues has been even partially addressed by this deal, but it has not been fixed.

This deal only makes a few small changes. First, it would permit judicial review of Section 215 gag orders, but under conditions that would make it very difficult for anyone to obtain meaningful judicial review. Under the deal, judicial review can only take place after a year has passed and can only be successful if the recipient of the Section 215 order proves that that government has acted in bad faith. As many of us have argued in the context of the National Security Letters, that is a virtually impossible standard to meet. We need meaningful judicial review of these gag orders, not just the illusion of it.

Second, the deal would specifically allow the government to serve National Security Letters on libraries if the library comes within the current requirements of the NSL statute. This is a provision that appears to just restate current law. Even the American Library Association has called it a "fig leaf."

And third, the deal would clarify that people who receive a National Security Letter or a Section 215 order would not have to tell the FBI if they consult with an attorney. This last change is a positive step, but it is only one relatively minor change.

So that is what we are left with: one relatively minor improvement. That is nowhere near enough.

Ordinarily, when we debate a flawed bill like this one, we have the chance to improve it by offering amendments. I've been trying to do just that to make sure that we don't miss this opportunity to address the core problems with the Patriot Act that so many of us have been fighting to fix. Before the recess I filed four amendments to S. 2271, but I was prevented from calling them up because the Majority Leader used the procedural tactic of filling the amendment tree in order to prevent Senators from offering and getting votes on amendments. Using procedural maneuvers like this to prevent the Senate from debating and voting on amendments is an insult to this institution and to every one of my colleagues. We are being told we have no choice but to accept a deal that a few members cut with the White House, without changing a word.

We do have a choice -- to oppose cloture on this bill and insist that any deal include meaningful civil liberties protections. I don't know if the Majority Leader fears that my amendments would actually pass, or if he just wants to protect Senators from having to explain why they oppose basic protections for law-abiding Americans. But that should not be how the Senate does its business. Offering, debating and voting on amendments is what the Senate is supposed to be all about ­ that's how we craft legislation. Trying to ram this deal through without a real amending process is a cynical maneuver that we should all reject, regardless of how we may feel about the merits of the bill. If my colleagues wish to vote against my amendments, that is their right. But no one has the right to turn this body into a rubber stamp.

Let's take a step back and consider the process that got us here today. As we all know, conference reports are not amendable. They come to this body as a take it or leave it proposition. Those are the rules and we all understand them and play by them. In December, we said no to the Patriot Act conference report.

Now we have a new bill, the product of a side-deal with the White House, that is essentially an amendment to the conference report. It is even drafted that way. Each section of the bill amends the underlying law, as amended by the conference report. That's right. The bill we are considering today amends a law that hasn't even been passed by the Senate, much less signed into law. As I understand it, this bill, should both Houses of Congress pass it, will have to sit on the President's desk unsigned until the President signs the conference report into law.

So proponents of this deal want to effectively amend the conference report which couldn't pass the Senate in December, even though conference reports are unamendable. And they want to do it by circumventing the regular legislative process with a bill that no one is being allowed to amend ­ even though the bill did not even go through committee, let alone a conference. How is that fair? Why should a handful of members of this body be able to amend an unamendable conference report with a deal struck with the White House, and then prevent the Senate from working its will on that deal? How can one group of Senators amend the conference report but prevent other Senators from trying to do the same thing? How is that possible?

The answer is that it's not possible, unless the Senate lets it happen. And the vote we will have later today is the vote where we will find out if the Senate will let it happen.

I hope that even colleagues who may support the deal will oppose such a sham process. It makes no sense to agree to end debate without a guarantee that we will be allowed to actually try to improve the bill. And it is a discourtesy to all Senators, not just me, to try to ram through controversial legislation without the chance to improve it.

My amendments are limited and reasonable. I spoke at length about them before the recess, but let me just take a few minutes to explain again what they would do.

First, Amendment No. 2892 would implement the standard for obtaining Section 215 orders that was in the Senate bill that the Judiciary Committee approved by a vote of 18 to 0, and that was agreed to in the Senate without objection. This is a reasonable amendment that every Senator in one way or another has basically supported.

It took hard work, but the Judiciary Committee came up with language on Section 215 that protects innocent Americans while also allowing the government to do what is needs to do to investigate and prevent terrorism. The Senate standard would require the government to convince a judge that a person has some connection to terrorism or espionage before obtaining their sensitive records. The Senate standard is the following: (1) that the records pertain to a terrorist or spy; (2) that the records pertain to an individual in contact with or known to a suspected terrorist or spy; or (3) that the records are relevant to the activities of a suspected terrorist or spy. And that is the standard that my amendment would impose. This would not limit the types of records that the government could obtain, and it does not go as far to protect law-abiding Americans as I might prefer, but it would make sure the government cannot go on fishing expeditions into the records of innocent people.

The conference report did away with this delicate compromise, replacing the three-prong test with a simple, and quite broad, relevance standard, which could arguably justify the collection of all kinds of information about law-abiding Americans.

Of all the concerns that have been raised about the Patriot Act since it was passed in 2001, Section 215 is the one that has received the most public attention, and rightly so. A reauthorization bill that doesn't fix this provision, in my view, has no credibility.

My second amendment is Amendment No. 2893, which would ensure that recipients of business records orders under section 215 of the Patriot Act and recipients of National Security Letters can get meaningful judicial review of the gag orders that they are subject to.

Under the conference report, as modified by the Sununu bill, recipients of these documents would theoretically have the ability to challenge the gag orders in court, but the standard for getting the gag orders overturned would be virtually impossible to meet. In order to prevail in challenging the NSL or Section 215 gag order, the recipient would have to prove that any certification by the government that disclosure would harm national security or impair diplomatic relations was made in bad faith. There would be what many have called a "conclusive presumption" that the gag order stands, unless the recipient can prove that the government acted in bad faith. That is not meaningful judicial review.

My amendment would eliminate the "bad faith" showing currently required for overturning both section 215 and NSL gag orders. And it would no longer require recipients of section 215 orders to wait a year before they can challenge the accompanying gag orders, which is a new requirement included in the Sununu bill.

My third amendment, Amendment No. 2891, would add to the conference report one additional 4-year sunset provision. It would sunset the National Security Letter authorities that were expanded by the Patriot Act. It would simply add that sunset to the already existing 4-year sunsets that are in the conference report with respect to section 206, section 215, and the lone wolf provision.

National Security Letters, or NSLs, are finally starting to get the attention they deserve. This authority was expanded by sections 358 and 505 of the Patriot Act. The issue of NSLs has flown under the radar for years, even though many of us have been trying to bring more public attention to it.

National Security Letters are issued by the FBI to businesses to obtain certain types of records, without any court approval whatsoever. NSLs can be used to obtain three types of business records: subscriber and transactional information related to Internet and phone usage; credit reports; and financial records, a category that has been expanded to include records from all kinds of everyday businesses like jewelers, car dealers, travel agents and even casinos. This is a very broad power, and I can think of no reason why Congress would not want to place a sunset on these authorities to ensure we have the opportunity to take a close look at them.

Finally, my fourth amendment, Amendment No. 2894, concerns so-called "sneak and peek" searches, whereby the Government can secretly search people's houses in everyday criminal investigations and not provide notice of the search until afterward. The key issue here is how long the government should be allowed to wait, at least in most cases, before it notifies individuals that their homes have been searched. The Senate bill said seven days should be the presumption, with the ability to get extensions if necessary. But the conference report does away with that and instead allows a delay of 30 days in most cases.

My amendment would restore the key component of the Senate compromise by requiring that subjects of sneak and peek searches be notified of the search within 7 days, unless a judge grants an extension of that time because there is a good reason to still keep the search secret. It makes no other change to the conference report other than changing 30 days to 7 days.

Those are my amendments. They are eminently reasonable. They are consistent with provisions that we approved in the Senate last year, or they were central to the concerns raised by so many Senators late last year. So these are obviously not extreme ideas. And the Senate should be allowed to vote on these four amendments. All of us have as much right as the Senators who struck a deal with the White House do, to try to amend the conference report.

I'm happy to report that the Senator from Pennsylvania thinks these are reasonable amendments too. In fact, he thinks they are so reasonable that late yesterday he announced that he is going to combine them into a single bill and introduce it today, and try to move it in the Judiciary Committee. That's right, the Chairman of the Judiciary Committee, the chief proponent in this body of the Patriot Act reauthorization conference report and of the White House deal the Senate is being asked to ratify, has taken the four amendments I just described and, with a few minor tweaks, introduced them as a bill.

I must say, I am flattered. And of course I will support that bill. But there is an alternative to the lengthy and uncertain legislative process that awaits the Chairman's new bill. And that is to allow the Senate to vote on my amendments. The Chairman could offer them with me. We would make a powerful team I'm sure. And we have the perfect and logical vehicle for these amendments to the Patriot Act before us right now. All we need to do is add the Chairman's reasonable proposals to this bill and send it to the House where it would almost certainly pass if the leadership would allow it to be voted on. These provisions, most of which come right out of the bill that passed the Senate without objection last July, could become law in a matter of weeks, rather than a year or more from now, if ever.

My amendments, and Senator Specter's bill, are simply what the bipartisan group asked for back in December when we blocked the Patriot Act reauthorization conference report. Our requests were reasonable then, and they are reasonable now. The only reason we are considering a package that doesn't include them is that the White House played hardball, and some Senators decided they had to capitulate.

I oppose the flawed deal we are being asked to ratify. And I oppose the sham process that the Senate is facing here. We still have not fixed some of the most significant problems with the Patriot Act, and if we allow the conference report to go through, the Chairman's sincere hopes notwithstanding, I fear we will lose that chance for another four years. So I must oppose cloture on this bill, which will allow the deal to go forward.





 

Finally Available
from CounterPunch Books!
The Case Against Israel
By Michael Neumann

Click Here to Order Michael Neumann's Devastating Rebuttal of Alan Dershowitz

WHAT'S INSIDE
Grand Theft Pentagon:
Tales of Greed and Profiteering in the War on Terror

by Jeffrey St. Clair

 

CounterPunch Speakers Bureau

Sick of sit-on-the-Fence speakers, tongue-tied and timid? CounterPunch Editors Alexander Cockburn and Jeffrey St Clair are available to speak forcefully on ALL the burning issues, as are other CounterPunchers seasoned in stump oratory. Call CounterPunch Speakers Bureau, 1-800-840-3683. Or email beckyg@counterpunch.org.

The Book on 9/11 the White House Denounced as "ABSOLUTE GARBAGE"